Proper Coffee

Bakers Yard BakeryKelham Island, Sheffield

★EverydayThe everyday answer

Bakers Yard0.2 mi from Kelham Island centrelast reviewed April 2026

The pastries are the main event in Kelham Island. The batch brew is good enough that people leave with bags of beans.

A Kelham Island bakery where the batch brew sells bags of beans on the way out.

4.8★★★★½(132)
Reviews from Google Maps
Beans to go

What we love

  • •Batch brew praised highly enough that at least one visitor bought retail beans on the spot
  • •Retail coffee beans stocked on-site, suggesting an intentional sourcing relationship
  • •Long black is the order for regulars who know what they want
  • •Espresso drinks well-made; cappuccino and flat white described as rich and flavour-forward

Location

1 Bakers Yard, Sheffield S3 8BY, UK

0.2 mi from Kelham Island centre

Open in Google Maps
View Website

From the Journal

View all pieces →

Richaro's Ramblings · 4 May

The case for Everyday

Proper Coffee surfaces three tiers. We lean on the top one because that's the obvious thing a discovery site should do, and that's mostly where this site sends…

Also in Sheffield

See all →
Foundry Coffee Roasters★★ Specialty

Foundry roast on site at Cutlery Works, so the beans on the counter are the same ones in your cup. Described by origin, which makes the retail shelf worth a look.

The Depot Bakery★ Everyday

Assembly Coffee poured properly in a Kelham Island bakery that treats the espresso with the same seriousness as the sourdough. Off-menu split shots taken without hesitation.

Frazer's Coffee Roasters★★★ Purist
City Centre

Frazer roasts on-site in a machine he built himself, with national awards to show for it. The team know the pre-release stock and will pull something not yet on the floor if you ask.