Proper Coffee

Coffee Rules SheffieldCity Centre, Sheffield

EverydayThe everyday answer

Haymarket0.5 mi from City Centre centrelast reviewed April 2026

Greek-owned with Dimello espresso on the machine and traditional Greek coffee on the menu. Fills a real gap in a part of the City Centre where the default is a chain.

Dimello beans and Greek coffee culture in a corner of Sheffield that needed both.

4.8★★★★½(48)
Reviews from Google Maps

What we love

  • Dimello espresso: Greek specialty roaster, sustainably sourced and roasted in Greece
  • Traditional Greek coffee on the menu alongside standard espresso drinks
  • Staff who know the cultural context behind Greek coffee, not just running shots
  • Independent option in Haymarket when everything else is a chain

Location

17 Haymarket, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2AW, UK

0.5 mi from City Centre centre

From the Journal

View all pieces →

Also in Sheffield

See all →
Frazer's Coffee Roasters★★★ Purist

Frazer roasts on-site in a machine he built himself, with national awards to show for it. The team know the pre-release stock and will pull something not yet on the floor if you ask.

2323 Coffee★★ Specialty

The founders are still behind the bar, rotating single origins every couple of weeks and running coffee flights for anyone who wants to go further. The people who have worked through Sheffield's specialty scene keep ending up back here.

Coffee @ Moor Market★★ Specialty

Brew Moor is Sheffield's own roastery, operating from a stall inside Moor Market rather than a dedicated space. Everything is roasted in-house, and the beans are on the shelf to take home.