Proper Coffee

Motore CafeCity Centre, Sheffield

★EverydayThe everyday answer

Sheaf Square0.3 mi from City Centre centrelast reviewed April 2026

Darkwoods Coffee poured from a hand-built trailer outside the station since 2012. Stay for a cannoli.

Darkwoods Coffee and Our Cow Molly milk from a railway station trailer.

4.8★★★★½(91)
Reviews from Google Maps
Pour-over

What we love

  • •Darkwoods Coffee (Crow Tree blend), a recognised Yorkshire specialty roaster
  • •Milk from Our Cow Molly, delivered within 12 hours of milking
  • •Espresso menu only, no filter

Location

Sheaf Square, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2BP, UK

0.3 mi from City Centre centre

Open in Google Maps
View Website

From the Journal

View all pieces →

Richaro's Ramblings · 4 May

The case for Everyday

Proper Coffee surfaces three tiers. We lean on the top one because that's the obvious thing a discovery site should do, and that's mostly where this site sends…

Also in Sheffield

See all →
Frazer's Coffee Roasters★★★ Purist

Frazer roasts on-site in a machine he built himself, with national awards to show for it. The team know the pre-release stock and will pull something not yet on the floor if you ask.

2323 Coffee★★ Specialty

The founders are still behind the bar, rotating single origins every couple of weeks and running coffee flights for anyone who wants to go further. The people who have worked through Sheffield's specialty scene keep ending up back here.

Coffee @ Moor Market★★ Specialty

Brew Moor is Sheffield's own roastery, operating from a stall inside Moor Market rather than a dedicated space. Everything is roasted in-house, and the beans are on the shelf to take home.