Proper Coffee

Cafe at The Old RectoryHastings

★EverydayThe everyday answer

The Old Rectory1 mi from Hastings centrelast reviewed October 2026

A food-led café on the edge of Hastings old town, where the coffee holds its own against house-smoked fish and cakes that change often. Take the garden table if the sun is out.

A Hastings kitchen that takes its coffee as seriously as its smoked fish.

4.8★★★★½(34)
Reviews from Google Maps

What we love

  • •Coffee singled out as excellent, and called real coffee, by multiple visitors
  • •Fish smoked on the premises
  • •Homemade cakes that change often
  • •Kombucha on the menu
  • •Sunny garden to sit in

Location

The Old Rectory, 2 Harold Rd, Hastings TN35 5ND, UK

1 mi from Hastings centre

From the Journal

View all pieces →

Also in Hastings

See all →
Good Grades★★ Specialty

A converted house on Hastings High Street where the espresso is a single origin, with its origin, varietal and tasting notes printed at the grinder. Order it as an espresso; it holds up better than most seaside cafés manage.

Cafe La Mer★ Everyday

An owner-run counter in Hastings where the cortado and flat white are judged right and the latte comes out sweet, never bitter or sour. Worth a stop on the way past Wellington Place.

Caffe Galleria★ Everyday

An arcade counter in Hastings pouring cappuccinos with properly textured milk, a rarer thing than it should be. Stay for the toasties and pastries.

Run this café? Add the Proper Coffee badge to your site